Reviewed by Nikki Cotter

Opening Night verdict ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Hope Mill Theatre’s Lizzie gained an army of fans with its original run in September 2023, with many theatre fans making multiple visits, often in Lizzie inspired costumes, while social media was awash with praise, now, comes the turn of an all-new 2024 cast to make their mark on this firm audience favourite. Driven by a killer score delivered by four absolute power-house female performers, Lizzie raises the roof of this much-loved Manchester venue and takes every audience member along for an exhilarating ride.

The infamous story of Lizzie Borden who was famously accused of brutally murdering her father and stepmother in the summer of 1892 may not be the most obvious material for a musical, but my goodness does it deliver! With a small cast of four this is a vibrant exploration of fierce women controlling their destiny at a time when oppression was the norm.

Director and choreographer William Whelton takes these historical figures and ensures that their stories are told in bold, blistering style. Opening with the eerie, infamous nursery rhyme we’re immediately transported into an intense and pressured environment. As the thrilling opening bars of House of Borden kick in, the scene is set for an electrifying production bursting with powerful vocals, edgy choreography, emotional depth and boundless female energy.

Kayleigh McKnight commands the stage as Lizze, you’re never quite sure what she’ll do next while her vocals are to die for. Fiery and ferocious one moment, calm and composed the next, she convincingly and comfortably shifts to vengeful as she takes action to gain control of her life.

McKnight has a wonderful connection with Katie Tonkinson, who plays Lizzie’s best friend and love interest Alice, their relationship is gently and delicately revealed by Tonkinson who brings light to this dark tale with her pitch-perfect, emotive performance. She truly shines in the role.

Emilie Louise Israel is superb as Lizzie’s older sister Emma, she’s strong and decisive while her rich vocals are utterly sublime. Jennifer Caldwell engages the audience from the start as housemaid come narrator Bridget. She packs in the humour with her brilliantly expressive performance, while relishing the menacing threat that something’s about to happen and we quickly get the feeling that she’ll be delighted when it does.

Accompanying this powerhouse cast is an all-female band led by Musical Director Ella Ingram, they are electrifying and further amplify the rebellious, empowering vibe.

Andrew Exeter’s set design and incredible lighting is complimented brilliantly by Dan Light’s vibrant video design, transporting Lizzie from the claustrophobic confides of the Borden House to a place where her hopes and dreams can take flight.

This gripping musical is loud, unapologetic and utterly brilliant. The layered storytelling keeps you engaged throughout while the searing score and gritty lyrics hook you in from the start. This talented cast deliver demanding vocals with an impressive ease; their harmonies are to die for while their transformation into a kick-ass girl group by the finale is deliciously satisfying. Lizzie is back, and as bloody brilliant as ever, unmissable!

Lizzie is on at Hope Mill Theatre until Sunday 17th November, tickets available here.