A Christmas Carol Goes Wrong

Reviewed by Gill Selkirk

Opening Night verdict ⭐⭐⭐⭐

If it’s belly laughs, you’re after, then get yourself down to the Opera House this week where Mischief Theatre are dishing them out thick and fast as they bring their hilarious A Christmas Carol Goes Wrong to Manchester.

Starring original West End cast member, this play within a play sees the ever-chaotic Cornley Amateur Drama Society audition, rehearse and then perform their take on the Dickens classic with hilarious results.

From start to finish, the whole thing is a delicious disaster, there’s massive miscommunication, backstage beef, forgotten lines, broken sets, missed cues, bitter rivalries and egos that threaten to eclipse the telling of the actual story. There are bellringers, swordfights, Malteasers and puppets all involved in this carnival of chaos.

The play within a play flips Charles Dickens’s beloved classic on its head, as Tiny Tim into a gigantic monster while Scrooge is left even more bitter than how he started. The crazed feats of sabotage between arrogant director Chris (Henry Shields) and pompous actor Robert, (Henry Lewis), who has a preference for acting in the nude are classic Mischief territory and gosh do they do it well. Add to this delusional Dennis (Jonathan Sayer) whose sole research has been The Muppets Christmas Carol, and you’ve got the perfect recipe for disaster and that’s even before we’ve mentioned the ghosts.

Henry Lewis is consistently hilarious as Robert, taking on the Ghost of Christmas Present while wearing a giant gift-wrapped box. Meanwhile, Allie Dart brings manic energy to Annie, as a wildly gyrating Ghost of Christmas Past. Completing the trio is Chris Leask’s Trevor as the Ghost of Christmas Future, (and my son’s personal favourite) who pulls off a masterclass in physical comedy from inside an impressively enormous costume.

Libby Todd’s set designs are superb, while Roberto Surace has clearly had great fun with the impressive and outlandish costume design.

This wouldn’t be A Christmas Carol without a redemption story as we see the real warmth happen backstage, where despite being too cheap to turn on the heating, self-absorbed director Chris finally softens toward his fellow cast members and they wonderfully warm up to him in return.

This is a perfect way to start your Christmas festivities and a real treat for regional audiences to see writers Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields reprise their West End roles delivering non-stop festive cheer from start to finish. Mischief Theatre’s signature blend of impeccable comedic timing, escalating chaos, and genuine heart proves once again to be an unbeatable formula. Whether you are a longtime fan of their “Goes Wrong” productions or simply looking for a brilliant night out with the family, this show is guaranteed to leave you roaring with laughter and bursting with seasonal spirit.

Leave a Reply