Paula Tappenden

Blood Brothers

Leave a comment

Reviewed by Sophie Rowley

Opening Night verdict ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

So here we find ourselves as Blood Brothers embarks on its 42nd year on opening night at the Lowry Lyric Theatre. The one thing I love when going to the theatre is sitting in the foyer waiting for the show to start. The anticipation from the audience chatting and excitement knowing they are in for a great show. Blood Brothers is no exception to this, hailed the “standing ovation musical” this show promises to be “unmissable”, bringing audiences worldwide to it feet with “applause” and “approval”. With such acclaim its a wonder that this is my first time seeing Blood Brothers, I too share the same anticipation and hope as the audience members currently waiting to take their seats.

Blood Brothers originated as a short play written by Willy Russell in 1981, a play that 2 years later he developed into a full musical; its very first performance was January 8th 1983 at Liverpool Playhouse with Barbara Dickson and Andrew Schofield taking the lead roles. Russell often explores themes of social class inequality, fate, the importance of family and friendships. So the big question for me is, after over 4 decades and countless worldwide performances does Blood Brothers still fit into today’s society.

Bob Thompson’s and Bill Kenwright’s direction of Blood Brothers bring this show to life, as the plot centres around twins who were separated at birth only to be reunited with tragic and disastrous consequences. Russell’s talent is further seen in the Blood Brothers score which is driven by the raw and real  problems of working class life, it is this generic quality that has resulted in the show being dubbed “the Liverpudlian Folk Opera”. Instead of using the music to drive the plot, I would argue the songs act as characters themselves allowing them to serve as a chance for the protagonists to reflect. Moreover the music is very simplistic, mainly comprised of piano and saxophone. This combination of an understated score and little to no moments for applause from the audience made the show more haunting. The first applause being at end of the first half and the second  at the end of the show.

The set was very minimal and understated – the main focal point was the Liverpool skyline, the green country landscape and the terrace housing. This occasionally changed to show the Lyon’s residence or Mrs Johnstone’s new country abode. Again a very clever production choice as it allows the plot to drive itself.

Russell’s signature style of social values and inequality are presented in such a way that it almost feels like he is trying to stun the audience into the reality of working class hardships. The difference between Mickey and Eddie’s upbringing highlights the age old question of nature versus nurture. We see the twins navigate through their childhood and adolescence with the normal teenage rebellion and peer pressures as Russell appears to be asking the audience – how far does fate play a part in the journey to adulthood.

Reprising their roles are Sean Jones as Mickey Johnstone and Joe Sleight as Eddie Lyon. Sean Jones’ portrayal of Mickey is quite brilliant as he brings a raw and real authenticity to the character; and honestly watching him I can’t help but draw multiple parallels with todays society and the social and political problems we are seeing in 2025. Similarly Joe Sleight’s characterisation of Eddie pairs perfectly with Jones’ and at times you forget you are watching a show – more if feels as though you’re a fly on the wall for conversations you shouldn’t be hearing.

Straight from the west end – Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone is emotionally charged, she presents Mrs Johnstone in such a haunting way that you cant help but feel sorry for her. Her continuous reprise of Marilyn Monroe further shows how tragic this character really is. The audience see Mrs Johnstone’s bravery in making hard family decisions and instantly see the devastation these decisions cause. The song “Tell Me It’s Not True” can’t fail but bring a tear to your eyes. Paula Tappenden returns as Mrs Lyon’s, her Thatcherite fashion and conservative values demonstrate the difference between the 2 mothers. Kristofer Hardings continues his role as the narrator, continuously breaking the fourth wall with his Shakespearean style rhymes, he almost forces the audience to question their own morals. Gemma Brodrick’s portrayal of Linda brings humour and light to the show – but again fate does not spare her from hardships.

In conclusion, Blood Brothers is not for the faint hearted – it is not a happy mood boosting musical, rather it is a gut wrenching take on society and how far are we in control of our destiny. It’s almost Dickensian in its portrayal of working class hardship presented alongside wealth and entitlement. Coming back to my original question at the start – does Blood Brothers still have a place in 2025? Yes, absolutely it does. Kenwright and Thompson bring Russells play to life remarkably well, through an emotionally charged score and characters who could quiet easily fit into today’s society. It’s rightly earned the title of ‘standing ovation musical’ and I couldn’t help but join in. It could be argued that not only is Blood Brothers still relevant today but I would go further and say we need more shows like this in theatres – and the fact that this show was written in 1981 and is still selling out venues worldwide in its 42nd year completely justifies this view, and it rightly deserves a 5 star review.

Blood Brothers

2 Comments

 

Reviewed by Alex Broadley

Opening Night verdict ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Blood Brothers is one of those shows which some might think is a standard touring musical, a staple for theatre-goers everywhere. However, Blood Brothers is embarking on its 30th Anniversary tour for a reason, it has stood the test of time for over 3 decades and its themes of class, money and love are as relevant as ever.

Written and composed by Willy Russell the man behind Educating Rita and Shirley Valentine, Blood Brothers’ first audiences were school children. He wanted to make sure that he hooked the children sitting in the back row of the class and Blood Brothers certainly does that. The show was soon picked up for a short run in the West End and thus began its epic journey to becoming the theatrical juggernaut it is today.

Blood Brothers tells the tragic tale of the Johnstone twins, two brothers separated at birth. Their mother Mrs Johnstone (Linzi Hateley) struggling with mounting debt and the need to feed seven growing children, simply cannot afford to keep both of her babies. Enter Mrs Johnstone’s employer Mrs Lyons (played convincingly by Paula Tappenden); Mrs Lyons cannot have children and the pain is etched on her face. In a fateful deal, Mrs Johnstone gives away one child (Joel Benedict as Edward) and keeps the other (Mickey, played by Alexander Patmore).

The play opens, as many great plays do (think Phantom of the Opera), with the ending. From the beginning, we know how it will play out and this adds to the sense of foreboding and tragedy. Narrator (Robbie Scotcher) asks us to make up our own minds – does Mrs Johnstone have a stone in place of her heart? Scotcher is ever present; he is our slightly menacing moral compass, questioning the characters’ decisions and reminding us of their inevitable fates.

The brothers continue to meet, drawn together by fate and across the class divide which will eventually tear them apart. Time is moved swiftly and effectively on by Scotcher and we see Mickey and Eddie grow up and become young men, albeit with very different lives and opportunities.

Russell’s aim was for the music to be woven into the story and the songs and musical patterns weave themselves throughout the narrative. The soundscape is dramatic and occasionally builds up to a crescendo loud enough to make the audience wince along with the drama. Stand out songs include Tell me it’s not true and Marilyn Monroe.

Andy Walmsley’s set design is simple but effective. The claustrophobic feel of the Liverpool slums and the contrasting bright feel of the Lyons’ living room take us back to the 1950s/60s but also show the class divide which runs throughout Blood Brothers.

The cast is fantastic and extremely hard working. Alexander Patmore’s Mickey is full of cheeky humour and grit. The scenes when Mickey (Patmore) and Eddie (Benedict) are children are stand out moments and take you back to playing out after school and not having a care in the world. Benedict is likeable as the naïve and privileged Eddie Lyons and the relationship between Mickey and Eddie is affectionate and deep. Linzi Hateley is strong as Mrs Johnstone; full of gumption and humour, you feel for the tough hand life has dealt her. Her character is the lynchpin of the play. Danielle Corlass’ character of Linda is caught in the middle of the class and brotherly divide; she is funny and well meaning.

Blood Brothers is a staple of musical theatre. Everyone should see it. It offers you an evening (or afternoon) filled with humour, tragedy, grit and will leave you feeling as though you’ve been on an emotional rollercoaster. Bring a handkerchief for those inevitable sniffles.

Blood Brothers is on at The Lowry, Salford until Saturday 13th April.here.