Reviewed by Matt Forrest

Opening Night verdict ⭐⭐⭐

The Brit Awards rolled into Manchester weekend just past, and not for the first time   Manchester was the music epicentre of the universe, a hyperbolic claim that Anthony H Wilson would have endorsed if he were still with us today. However, what is not an exaggeration is that one of the key factors in the story of popular music in Manchester is the importance and influence of Joy Division.

Writer Brian Gorman’s play New Dawn Fades charts the rise of Joy Division while weaving in a potted history of the great city of Manchester — or Mamucium, as it was christened by the Romans.

The play opens with “Mr Manchester” himself Tony Wilson in full television-presenter mode (Brian Gorman), brandishing a This Is Your Life red book as he introduces the band’s key figures: frontman Ian Curtis (Josh Lonsdale), guitarist Bernard Sumner (Garient Lyons), bassist Peter Hook (Gaz Hayden), and drummer Stephen Morris (Jack McGarry). Completing the picture and central to the band’s story is Debbie Curtis (Lauren Greenwood), Ian’s wife. Wilson himself was an essential part of the Joy Division story signing them to Factory, the record label he co-founded.

As we’re given an inside track on the band’s formation, we’re also offered a vivid snapshot of life in 1970s Manchester, capturing the raw energy of the punk movement and the seismic influence of bands such as Sex Pistols and Buzzcocks on the city’s cultural identity. Along the way, the audience is treated to a brisk history lesson exploring Manchester’s origins and what makes it so distinctive.

As the band begins to garner success, which means more tours and more live shows, the mounting pressures begin to take their toll on Curtis, straining his marriage, testing his relationships within the band, and exacerbating his fragile physical/mental health with devastating consequences.

New Dawn Fades has all the ingredients to be something truly special; however, it doesn’t always fully come together. When it works, though, it works well. Josh Lonsdale is outstanding as Curtis, completely capturing the intensity of the man, nowhere more so than in the electrifying renditions of Joy Division classics “Shadowplay,” “Transmission,” and “Love Will Tear Us Apart.” Yet it is Lonsdale’s portrayal of the debilitating impact of epilepsy on Curtis that resonates most powerfully.

Brian Gorman delivers a fantastic performance as Tony Wilson. His delivery is uncanny, and he does a spot-on job of bringing Wilson’s mannerisms and at times self-aggrandising nature to life. Lauren Greenwood is good as Debbie, though somewhat underused; you can’t help but feel it was a missed opportunity not to explore more of her perspective and give greater depth to her side of the story.

Where the show misses a trick, is with the live song performances, of the band only Lonsdale  seemed to be performing live, whilst the rest of the band played a long to a backing track, it seems an odd choice considering that all the actors are musicians as well.

The narrative flow also stutters at times. Scene transitions are marked by quick blasts of music as the lights abruptly drop and rise again. The effect can feel jarring and would benefit from a smoother, more seamless approach.

There is, however, much to admire. The playfulness of the first half, using figures such as a Roman general and Friedrich Engels to frame Manchester’s story, adds invention and humour. The band dynamics are engaging, particularly the fiery presence of Peter Hook balanced against Bernard Sumner’s more measured, calming nature, which brings welcome levity. This tonal lightness contrasts effectively with the darker intensity that follows the interval. That said, aside from Curtis, the band members are not fully fleshed out and at times feel somewhat superficial.

This is clearly a labour of love, created with deep affection for the band and the great city of Manchester. While there is much to enjoy, the production ultimately left me wondering what might have been, and wanting just a little more.

New Dawn Fades is on at the Lowry till 4th March tickets are available here.